The honest answer: there's no single "best" wax — each has a different character. Soy and coconut are soft plant waxes that suit container candles; beeswax burns long and smells faintly of honey; paraffin is cheap and carries a lot of fragrance. What the evidence does not support is the popular line that "soy is non-toxic and paraffin is toxic".
The four main waxes at a glance
| Wax | Made from | Strengths | Things to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soy | Hydrogenated soybean oil | Plant-based, creamy, great in jars | Soft; may show white "frosting" — harmless |
| Coconut | Coconut oil | Plant-based, very smooth top, good scent throw | Too soft on its own, so usually blended with soy |
| Beeswax | Made by honeybees | Long burn, gentle honey note | Expensive; its own scent can compete with fragrance |
| Paraffin | Petroleum refining | Cheap, holds lots of fragrance, the most widely used wax | Non-renewable source |
According to the US National Candle Association (NCA), paraffin is the most widely used candle wax worldwide, while soy and palm waxes arrived in the late 1990s, made by hydrogenating (hardening) vegetable oils.
What the emission studies found
The most detailed open study is Salthammer et al., published in Environment International in 2021. Researchers at Germany's Fraunhofer institute burned palm, paraffin, soy and stearin candles, scented and unscented, in a test chamber. Their conclusion: without fragrance, these waxes behave very similarly in terms of emissions. They also found that ultrafine particle levels were highest in the first 30–60 minutes of burning.
Context matters: the study was designed together with candle and fragrance manufacturers. An earlier 2007 study cited by the NCA also found no harmful differences between waxes, but it was industry-funded too.
What that means in practice:
- choose wax for what you enjoy — texture, scent, where the raw material comes from;
- a short wick and no drafts do more for a clean burn than the type of wax;
- ventilate the room, especially during longer burns.
Myth: beeswax purifies the air
You'll often read that beeswax candles release "negative ions" that clean the air. We couldn't find scientific studies supporting this. Atmospheric chemist Delphine Farmer (Colorado State University), speaking to a healthy-home blog, said there is no evidence for it — and that all candles, beeswax included, release soot and fine particles. Beeswax is a lovely material, but it isn't an air purifier.
What we use
Our candles are made with coconut wax, soy wax, or a blend of the two, depending on the candle. We like how they behave in a jar: a smooth, creamy surface, a soft flame and good scent throw — and we prefer plant-based raw materials. Each candle is 200 g, 8 cm across, with a 30–40 hour burn time.
Plant waxes look their best with a proper first burn and a trimmed wick — see how to burn a candle.
In short
- Soy and coconut: soft plant waxes, ideal in jars. Beeswax: long burn. Paraffin: cheap, strong scent.
- A 2021 study found unscented waxes behave very similarly when burned.
- Beeswax doesn't purify the air — that's a myth.
- The wick and drafts matter more for a clean burn than the wax type.